Home
>
Blog
>
Gift Ideas

14 Unique, Personalized Valentine’s Day Gifts That Are Cute, Not Cringe

Line illustration of a couple, framed and set on a shelf.

Written by Jennifer Heilbron

Listen, I’m never going to turn down a giant box of chocolates, flowers and a cute card that says how amazing and beautiful I am (also, did I mention amazing?). But, if my husband were to head to Etsy and create something unique and meaningful, my heart just might explode.


This year, I’m thinking outside the box and heading to Etsy for adorable and sentimental gifts that someone with far more talent than me will create and ship!


From a custom line drawing of your favorite photo together to underwear that stakes your claim, I’ve rounded up 14 fabulous Valentine’s Day that will make you fall in love with love!

14 Unique, Personalized Valentine’s Day Gifts

1

What’s for Dinner? Dice

$

$

15.99

$

Everyone knows that the number one argument that can tear even the most secure relationship apart is: WHAT SHOULD WE HAVE FOR DINNER? Take the decision-making out of it and toss these dice!

2

Embroidered Initial & Heart Sweatshirt

$

$

44.99

$

Not ready to commit to a tattoo with your honey’s initial? How about coordinating hoodies with your initials on each other’s sleeves? (Would make a great Galentine’s Day gift for your bestie, too!)

3

Personalized Golf Stamp

$

$

16.00

$

Get them something that makes them think of you when they're on the course for one too many hours! You can choose your initials, your wedding date or even a middle finger emoji. Hey, you do you, boo.

4

Personalized Photo Candle

$

$

23.99

$

Take one of your fave photos together and put it on a candle with a delicious scent and your own message. Draw a bath, dim the lights and bring out this beautiful candle for an extra romantic evening!

5

Custom Line Drawing

$

$

11.70

$

I’m always looking for artwork that feels unique, original, and has some personal meaning. This artist can turn any of your favorite photos into a minimalist digital piece in 6 hours!

6

Framed Song Lyrics

$

$

29.95

$

From your first dance at your wedding to the song that you put on in the car and you both sing to, this personalized vinyl lyrics poster is the best gift for honoring that special connection.

7

Custom Underwear

$

$

19.99

$

Hey, it's not just his heart that belongs to you! Why not shout it from the rooftops—or at least privately laugh about it in your bedroom.

8

Engraved Cast Iron Skillet

$

$

67.00

$

For a gift that will sizzle, no pun intended, this gift is perfect. Have your initials and anniversary date engraved on the back of the pan to keep things spicy for decades to come!

9

A Little Box of Reasons

$

$

20.00

$

This darling box comes with hearts etched with individual reasons you love your Valentine. From “I love your laugh” to “I love that you make me coffee every morning,” this is a sweet, personal gift.

10

Personalized Yoga Mat

$

$

19.20

$

You finally got your S.O. into yoga. Now, they just need a mat! You can personalize this no-slip mat with their name or initials, or even a word that might have an inside meaning to you both.

11

Custom Wood Razor

$

$

10.74

$

I love this wood razor with your spouse’s name engraved on it. Gift this with a really good quality shaving cream and cologne (if you’re feeling generous!), and this is a functional and fun gift!

12

I Love You Sound Wave

$

$

18.00

$

There is a reason why this is a best seller on Etsy! This handmade burlap print is custom drawn with an “I Love You” sound wave and your names and anniversary on it.

13

Dating App Mugs

$

$

26.31

$

Meet your happily-ever-after online? Featuring “You’re the best thing I found on the internet” on one mug with your names and a drawing of a phone on the other mug, this mug set is simply amazing!

14

Custom Note in an Egg

$

$

14.00

$

This teeny tiny quail egg comes with your personalized note, which can be anything from “Be My Valentine” to “Meet Me in the Bedroom!” It's a fun way to write a note without buying another card.

No items found.

No items found.

No items found.

No items found.

No items found.

No items found.

All of the products we feature are hand-selected by our editors! You see only what we love and what we think you'll love too. If you buy something through links on our site, Evite may earn a commission. Prices are subject to change.

No items found.
No items found.

Jennifer is a writer, mom of 3 and shopaholic. She lives in Los Angeles with her husband, 3 sons and endless amounts of Amazon deliveries.

View More Articles

View All